Fulvue Drive-In.com
Current Reviews
In Stores Soon
In Stores Now
DVD Reviews, SACD Reviews Essays Interviews Contact Us Meet the Staff
An Explanation of Our Rating System Search  
Category:    Home > Reviews > Action > Western > Supernatural > Superhero > Drama > Crime > Detective > Mystery > Serial Killer > TV > Jonah Hex (2010) + The Mentalist – The Complete Second Season (2009 - 2010/Warner DVDs)

Jonah Hex (2010) + The Mentalist – The Complete Second Season (2009 - 2010/Warner DVDs)


Picture: C+     Sound: B-     Extras: C/C-     Feature: C-/Episodes: C



Stories about people with some sixth or seventh ability, whether it is the ability to read the living and/or contact the dead.  However, the recent feature film of the DC Comics character Jonah Hex (2010) had a choice of using the ability for the title character to contact the dead or not.  That was a recent addition in the comic book history of the character, so the Neveldine/Taylor team had a choice to include it in the script and they did.  Once again, they botched a franchise.


In what plays like a discarded script for the Wild, Wild West movie (which itself really did use a discarded script from the Tim Burton/Nicolas Cage Superman film that never happened), Hex has to take on a cartoonish villain (John Malkovich getting an easy paycheck hamming it up), Megan Fox plays “the girl” and Warner watched the film go over-budget from reshoots, second guesses and even Josh Brolin (who can act) could not save the film as the title character.  Instead, it follows a constricted formula that makes it feel more like Catwoman than Dark Knight, the latter model of which it should have followed.  Maybe they hoped it would be another Ghost Rider, but that did not happen and if this had been made like a dark Western and Hex had no special powers, the film could have delivered.


Director Jimmy Hayward seems to have tried to make this work, but ultimately, it disappoints and just does not stay with you.  We have seen worse and supporting actors like Michael Shannon and Michael Fassbinder are ideal for this project, but too many things that could have gone wrong do.


In the meantime, The Mentalist goes on as a moderate hit TV show.  If you are not familiar with the show, we covered Season One at this link:





The Complete Second Season is more of the same and there is no real growth here in character development as the 23 hour-long (almost) shows become more about soap opera conflicts than taking off like the show should have.  This might be safe, but I cannot see this causing the show to last.  Simon Baker is good here, but I expected more and got less.


The anamorphically enhanced 2.35 X 1 image on Hex and 1.78 X 1 on Mentalist are sadly on par with each other, with both having softness, motion blur and limited depth.  Hex was shot in Super 35mm film format, but is so digitally gutted and plastered with visual effects overkill that the money in actual sets, locations and costumes is undermined and we doubt a Blu-ray would look much better.  Mentalist is simply the same old shaky camerawork again.  The Dolby Digital 5.1 mix on both have soundfields, but Hex seems to be sonically better, though limited by the old lossy codec.  Bet the Blu-ray sounds better.  Extras include Additional Scenes on both, while Mentalist adds two featurettes on the making of the show including its key concept.



-   Nicholas Sheffo


 Copyright © MMIII through MMX fulvuedrive-in.com