The Intouchables (2011/Weinstein/Sony Blu-ray)/La
Grande Illusion (1937/Lionsgate Blu-ray)/The Late Mathias Pascal (1926/Flicker Alley Blu-ray)/Rust & Bone (2012/Sony Blu-ray)/That Obscure Object Of Desire
(1977/Lionsgate Blu-ray)
Picture:
B-/B/B-/B/B- Sound: B/B-/C+/B-/B- Extras: C/B-/C+/C+/B Films: B-/A-/B-/C+/B-
Here is a
recent set of French films on Blu-ray including a classic, an art house
favorite, underseen silent gem and two recent releases that made an
international splash.
One of
the biggest hits in all of French cinema history, Eric Toledano and Olivier
Nakache co-directed The Intouchables
(2011) about the relationship that develops between a rich wheelchair-bound man
named Philippe (Francois Cluzet) and a streetwise man named Driss (Omar Sy) who
becomes his latest caretaker outside of the big house he owns. It is a drama, comedy and has some serious
moments (and maybe too much Earth, Wind & Fire music) that made for a
winning commercial mix that includes chemistry between the leads and a flow
that is appealing.
It even
is able to overcome its down times because of its energy and that is why it hit
so big there. The Weinsteins decided to
pick it up for the U.S.
market and though it got good critical response, it was not quiet the art house
hit it turned out to be, I think it will gain new fans as it moves from Blu-ray
and digital to other outlets over the next few years. No, it is not the greatest film I have ever
seen either, yet even I have to admit it plays like France today and the leads don’t
miss a beat. Also, that the co-directors
did not get in each other’s way is rare and a real plus. It is at least worth seeing once.
Extras
include some Deleted Scenes, but maybe there should have been more.
Give or
take Marcel Carne’s Children of Paradise,
Jean Renoir’s The Grand Illusion aka
La Grande Illusion (1937) is usually
considered the greatest French film ever made.
That says something, but even more than the many great Renoir films
including Rules Of The Game (see our
coverage of the Criterion Blu-ray elsewhere on this site) as the film
profoundly examines the human race, world politics, the failures of the Great
War that was supposed to be the war to end all wars and just before WWII began,
the film was able to take a deep look at WWI and everything about it that went
wrong and even how it should have never happened.
Jean
Gabin and Pierre Fresnay play French soldiers in a German POW Camp dealing with
being trapped and with a German Captain played perfectly by the great Erich Von
Stroheim in a visually brilliant film with a tremendous screenplay by Renoir
and Charles Spaak. It is pure cinema at
its finest, makes the big statement against the futility of wars of all kinds
and is boldly honest about all of it in the process.
I am
forever impressed in how this film never really ages, is as relevant as it ever
was and is even more influential now than when I first saw it so many years
ago. Yet, 76 years later, not enough
people have seen and heard what it has to say and many who should know better
have ignored its fine points. It also
marks the beginning of the maturity of the sound French Cinema with some other
classics at the time as an enduring source of great filmmaking that it remains
today long before and after the French New Wave. If you have never seen Grande Illusion, to say it is must-see viewing is an
understatement.
This fine
new upgraded edition has extras that include a Restoration featurette, Trailers
for the 1937 and 1958 theatrical releases, the John Truby film presentation and
three featurettes: La Grande Illusion:
Success, Controversy, The Original
Negative by Natacha Laurent and cinema professor and critic Ginette
Vincendreu’s look at the film.
Even less
known and seen is a silent gem from Director Marcel L’Herbier called The Late Mathias Pascal (1926) that has
two parts and lasts nearly three hours.
The first half is a sometimes deceptively simple melodrama about the
life of the title character (Ivan Mosjoukine in a really great performance) as
a man trying to have a good life, find live and a future. Instead, he finds poverty, annoyance,
dysfunctional toxic people and unhappy marriage with all of its trappings for
the worst. He still has dreams of a
better life and some of them are big.
After
this is well established and sometimes lavishly so, he finds his way to Monte Carlo and two
things happen: he wins a fortune and being absent so long, is reported
dead! Thrilled with the former and
shocked initially with the latter at first, he starts to see advantages to
being dead and having so much disposable income, decides to stay “dead” and
sees where this takes him.
The film
suddenly becomes a comedy with clever overtones and twists and turns that will
even surprise viewers 87 years later and counting. The rest of the cast is fine including key
actors of the era and Alberto Cavalcanti and Lazaro Meerson created the great
sets. Restored as nicely as can be for
now, this deserves some serious rediscovery and to take it place among all the
international silent classics because it is hard to do any kind of comedy at
this length and be successful, but the makers pulled it off here. Flicker Alley has done us all a favor by
bringing it out on Blu-ray and you should definitely go out of your way for it.
The only
extra is a nicely illustrated booklet on the film including informative text
and an essay by Richard Abel, but it is a good booklet up there with
Criterion’s best.
Jacques
Audiard’s Rust & Bone (2012) is
a drama about a man (Matthias Schoenaerts) who is a fighter, troubled man and
father traveling about to go to a relatives to stay until he can get things
going bringing his son with him. He is a
good man and father, but not always the best or most responsible dad. He also has a healthy interest in women and
is meeting new ones when he comes across a pretty, mysterious woman (Marion
Cotillard) who turns out to be a lady with an interesting job and one that will
change her life for the worst soon.
They
start to get to know each other better as things get darker for the both of
them and we watch wondering if things will get even worse.
Many bad
things happen and the way the film is set up, some of them feel like
self-fulfilling prophecy, robbing the film of some suspension of disbelief and
adding how it wallows in decay, stops it from having more character development
as well as leading to some predictability.
Fortunately, the leads are good together and acting is decent
throughout, but I expected a bit more and did not get it. Still, it is not a bad work overall and is
worth at least one look to see for yourself.
Extras
include a feature length audio commentary track by Audiard and Thomas Bidegain,
who co-wrote the screenplay together, Deleted Scenes with optional commentary,
VFX Breakdown with Mikros, a Making Of
featurette and On The Red Carpet: Toronto International Film Festival footage.
Finally,
we have Luis Buñuel’s That Obscure
Object Of Desire (1977) which is his unique take on aging and great twist
on virgin/whore complex as he has two actresses (a then-unknown Carole Bouquet
(Too Beautiful For You, For Your Eyes Only) and Angela Molina) in
what is still a groundbreaking film and one that also deals with politics, his
politics (including ideas of terrorist attacks) and his unique views of human
sexuality. Fernando Rey (The French Connection) is the man with
the obsessions and issues as the film thoroughly explores its subject matter in
a tight, energetic 103 minutes.
I always
liked the film and think it is still one of his best. Bouquet is highly underrated, Molina can act
and the rest of the cast is spot on.
Only rivaled by Grande Illusion
in complexity here, this is also a gem worth going out of your way for.
Extras
include three interview featurettes: Arbitrary
Desire (with Jean-Claude Carriére), Double
Dames (with Carole Bouquet and Angela Molina) and Dominique Maillet’s A Portrait Of Luis Buñuel with Pierre
Lary and Edmond Richard, all to be seen after watching the film.
The 1080p
digital High Definition image transfers on all the Blu-rays are pretty good,
with the prints used the best they could be.
The 1.33 X 1 image on Illusion
is greatly upgraded, the best the film has ever looked, and is joined by the
slightly stylized 2.35 X 1 image on Rust
as the best performers on the list. Right
behind them are the 1.85 X 1 image on Intouchables
(more stylized down than I would have liked), 1.33 X 1 on Pascal (the print still has its share of dirt and specks) and 1.66
X 1 on Desire (the color can be
faded in some shots) till have their demo visual moments just the same.
The
DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 5.1 lossless mix on Intouchables is the sonic champ here, even outdoing the same exact
DTS-MA codec mix on Rust, which is
more dialogue-based and can be more towards the front speakers than I would
have liked. Illusion and Desire both
have DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 2.0 Mono lossless mixes that sound better than
the films ever have before (both optical theatrical mono releases) leaving the lossy
Dolby Digital 2.0 Stereo scoring for Pascal
in last place by being a little limited and only so engaging despite being well
recorded otherwise.
- Nicholas Sheffo