The
Beatles 1+: Limited Edition
(2015/Apple/Capitol/Universal 2-Blu-ray/CD Set)/Martha
Davis & The Motels: Live At The Whiskey A Go Go - 50th
Anniversary Special
(2015/Vesuvio Blu-ray)/The
Who: 50 Years Of My Generation by Mat Snow
(2015/Hardcover/Race Point Books)
Picture:
B/B- Sound: B/B- Extras: B/C+ Main Programs: B+/B/Book: B
Here
are new releases from three of my favorite bands of all time, two
legends of the British invasion (including ones who started it) and a
new version of one of Rock & New Wave's greatest ever...
The
Beatles 1+
is a new expanded version (issued in several collectible forms &
in different formats) of the hit set album '1'
which reached #1 on album charts worldwide. This grand 2015 update
is highly welcome and we got the CD in a very high-quality DigiPak
book with built-in booklet that adds a 2-Blu-ray set with at least
one video clip for all 27 #1 hits (the band had 20 alone in the U.S.)
and more in
the U.K., so we start with the CD tracks...
Love
Me Do
From
Me To You
She
Loves You
I
Want To Hold Your Hand
Can't
Buy Me Love
A
Hard Day's Night
I
Feel Fine
Eight
Days A Week
Ticket
To Ride
Help!
Yesterday
Day
Tripper
We
Can Work It Out
Paperback
Writer
Yellow
Submarine
Eleanor
Rigby
Penny
Lane
All
You Need Is Love
Hello,
Goodbye
Lady
Madonna
Hey
Jude
Get
Back
The
Ballad of John and Yoko
Something
Come
Together
Let
It Be
The
Long and Winding Road
That
includes the title song of all four of their feature films, some of
the most covered/remade songs of all
time (with
Yesterday
the all-time champ by anyone) and only begins to scratch the surface
of their classics!
The
big surprise with the Blu-ray discs are many of the clips are more
obscure videotaped performances restored, upscaled and as upgraded as
possible. Serious money and effort have been put into fixing and
upgrading what we get here, some of which are rarer than you might
think. More on that below. To get specific, here's more on the
clips (all 1.33 X 1 unless otherwise stated) included...
Blu-ray
#1
Love
Me Do from the Mercey Sound TV series, filmed b/w,
8/24/63
From
Me To You from the Royal Variety Performance, b/w PAL videotape,
3/5/63
She
Loves You from Drop In,
b/w PAL videotape, 11/3/63
I
Want To Hold Your Hand from Late Scene Extra, b/w
PAL videotape, 11/25/63
Can't
Buy Me Love from the TV special Around The Beatles, b/w
APL videotape, 4/28/64
A
Hard Day's Night from the TV special Les Beatles, b/w PAL
videotape, 10/31/65
I
Feel Fine black & white PAL videotaped clip
Eight
Days A Week from the Shea Stadium Concert, 35mm, color,
8/15/65
Ticket
To Ride black & white videotaped clip
Help!
black & white videotaped clip
Yesterday
from The Ed Sullivan Show, b/w NTSC videotaped clip, 9/12/65
Day
Tripper black & white videotaped clip
We
Can Work It Out black & white videotaped clip
Paperback
Writer filmed 35mm color promo clip
Yellow
Submarine color clip from the restored version of the feature
film (1.78 X 1)
Eleanor
Rigby from color clip from the restored version of the feature
film (1.78 X 1)
Penny
Lane filmed color 35mm promo clip
All
You Need Is Love from special satellite broadcast live
performance, colorized version
Hello,
Goodbye filmed color promo clip from edits out of Magical
Mystery Tour
Lady
Madonna color filmed promo clip
Hey
Jude color PAL videotaped promo clip from The David Frost
Show with opening
Get
Back out of footage the film Let It Be
The
Ballad of John and Yoko from outtakes from filming of Let It
Be
Something
filmed color 35mm promo film
Come
Together CGI color promo clip released in 2000 (1.66 X 1)
Let
It Be is a reconstruction of a clip made in 1970
The
Long and Winding Road promo filmed during the making of Let
It Be
Blu-ray
#2
Twist
& Shout taped at the Odeon Cinema in Wales over a few nights
in 1963
Baby
It's You is a compilation of vintage footage & stills (color
and b/w) issued March 1995
Words
Of Love is a compilation of vintage footage issued 2013 with
Brian Epstein & Buddy Holly off of HDCAM master, similar to #2's
approach, plus some new animation
Please
Please Me live b/w NTSC videotaped clip (from DigiBeta source)
from 1963 eventually used on The Ed Sullivan Show
I
Feel Fine color promo clip #2 recorded 10/18/64 off of 2-inch
PAL videotape, 'fish & chips' version
Day
Tripper from The Music Of Lennon & McCartney TV
special from Granada Network b/w PAL videotape
Day
Tripper alternate b/w PAL videotaped 'variety show'-style clip
We
Can Work It Out b/w PAL videotaped promo clip
Paperback
Writer color PAL videotaped promo clip for Ed Sullivan Show
Rain
color filmed 35mm promo clip from the Chiswick House Gardens
Rain
videotaped b/w PAL version in new 2015 edit from vintage performance
footage of the song
Strawberry
Fields Forever is the classic full color 35mm filmed clip
Within
You Without You/Tomorrow Never Knows is the 2006 Love
medley video promo clip (1.78 X 1)
A
Day In The Life original color 16mm filmed promo clip
Hello,
Goodbye alternate, unreleased 35mm color filmed promo clip
Hello,
Goodbye second alternate, unreleased 35mm color filmed promo
clip
Hey
Bulldog 1999 reedit of 2/11/68 promo clip from 35mm film in
color
Hey
Jude alternate live performance promo clip from 2-inch color PAL
videotape from The David Frost Show
Revolution
live performance 2-inch color PAL videotape promo clip
Get
Back 2003 reedit version to promote the Let It Be...
Naked album from the documentary film Let It Be
from color 16m footage
Don't
Let Me Down another 2003 reedit version to promote the Let It
Be... Naked album from the documentary film Let It Be
Free
As A Bird standard definition 1995 music video clip (letterboxed
1.78 X 1) tied into The Beatles Anthology
Real
Love same as #22, but 1.33 X 1
That's
50 clips in all and they are very rewatchable, often iconic and are
more than enough to strongly recommend
this set overall. Classic footage that is iconic, legendary and
highly influential.
Martha
Davis & The Motels: Live At The Whiskey A Go Go - 50th
Anniversary Special
(2015) marks the biggest appearance we've seen of the band (albeit in
a new version, Miss Davis owns the band name, et al) since the
original members reunited a few years ago out of nowhere for a cable
TV series that was doing this for a different music act each show and
proved they still instantly had it. This new Blu-ray from the
Vesuvio label has Davis celebrating half a century of the legendary
venue while David herself celebrates her own birthday. Pulling from
an amazingly long list of underrated songs (deep cuts never issued as
singles) and some unforgettable key hits, the line up of includes...
1.
Party Professionals
2. Where Do We Go From Here
3. Mission Of
Mercy
4. Celia
5. Take The 'L'
6. Counting
7. Suddenly
Last Summer
8. Nothing
9. Danger
10. So L.A.
11.
Obvioso
12. Total Control
13. Closets and Bullets
14. Cry
Baby
15. Apocalypso
16. Mr. Grey
17. Only The Lonely
Songs
# 5, 7 and especially 17 were big hits and arguably classics with
remarkable music videos that played heavily on MTV to go with their
release, making them bigger hits than their singles charting would
suggest. Of course, there are gems like Icy
Red
and Remember
The Night,
not to mention tracks from Davis' underrated solo album not here, but
that's no problem as she and the new band truly deliver a show only I
wished were longer. The show delivered as expected and is easily one
of the best concert releases on Blu-ray of any genre all year, so
don't miss it!
Last
but not least is Mat Snow's very high quality, high content The
Who: 50 Years Of My Generation
(2015), a very
well-rounded volume on the history of the band with rare stills,
solid text, superior image reproduction and one that includes their
forays into feature films like Tommy
and Quadrophenia
(plus Ken Russell's Lisztomania,
which Roger Daltrey made with Russell the same year as Tommy,
all reviewed elsewhere on this site) so you get a true journey
through the printed page that is as good as most books on the band I
have seen over the years.
Of
course, those overly familiar with a certain police procedural TV
series and its endless spin-offs will associate some of the band's
hit songs with 'that show' but they more than hold up on their own as
the classics they are. It is hard to deliver a book that works on
one of the most written-about bands ever, but Snow delivers, so more
than fans should check this one out.
The
1080p 1.78 X 1 digital High Definition image on Beatles
consists mainly of classic clips of the band playing their #1 hits
and then some. Most of the clips actually originate on analog,
standard definition videotape (U.S. NTSC or U.K. PAL formats)
upscaled (to 1080i, though some film clips, like the entire Magical
Mystery Tour
Blu-ray, are also 1080i) and cleaned up to look as fine as possible,
but that does not make them high definition and they are all 1.33 X 1
clips centered in the 1.78 X 1 frame. In that, the work here is as
good as similar releases of upscaled Blu-rays from the Eagle and
Naxos labels, so they look as good as they are going to. All
You Need Is Love
is shown here in a colorized version only and I wish a black &
white/monochrome version had also been here to choose.
Most
of the filmed clips (likely Kodak in all color cases, except probably
Ilford film's Ilfocolor/Ilfochrome film stock on Penny
Lane)
are really impressive. Come
Together
looks fairly good for older CG animation and it turns out Free
As A Bird
and Real
Love
are standard-definition produced. The thing that will make fans
happiest are clips from the still-out-of-circulation Let
It Be
documentary showing up here restored in full color (the Rockumentary
was entirely shot on 16mm film, but 35mm dye-transfer,
three-strip Technicolor prints were issued, currently each worth a
small fortune if you have one) looking great.
The
1080p 1.78 X 1 digital High Definition image transfer can on
Motels
is a really good HD shoot that is about as stable and consistent than
most concert HD shoots we have seen from the other record labels and
mega independents Eagle and MVD Visual. Color is pretty good, there
is little in the way of detail issues despite some minor problems and
the presentation is smooth for the most part throughout.
As
for sound, Beatles
has all songs upgraded to DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 96 kHz 5.1
lossless mixes, which gets interesting for the early recordings and
original TV audio, all cleaned up and refined as much as possible, so
someone spent the time and money to do all this well. But it is on
the latter studio recordings that the sonics
really shine (Strawberry
Fields Forever,
Rain
and Let
It Be,
for instance) that the lossy Dolby Digital 5.1 and PCM 2.0 Stereo
version
cannot touch. Those who were impressed with the DTS audio on the
Criterion Hard
Day's Night,
Help!,
Yellow
Submarine
and Magical
Mystery Tour
Blu-rays (plus the DVD-Audio 5.1 lossless mix on the Love
set, if you have the capacity to play those tracks back) will be
pretty happy with the audio here throughout, as expected.
I
wanted lossless sound on The
Motels
Blu-ray, but sadly, we only get a lossy Dolby Digital 5.1 mix that
still sounds good, but you can tell that it is veiling and holding
back a much more dynamic soundmaster that would really shine in a
lossless version down to the musicianship and Davis' great voice.
Extras
include books in all cases, with a thick booklet built into the
DigiPak packaging of The
Beatles
release that is high quality thick paper and excellent stills (the
color is impressive), while Motels
has a booklet and Who
is a book in itself, but has no extras. Beatles adds a few intros on
select Videos by Ringo Starr and audio commentaries on select Videos
by Paul McCartney, leaving Motels
with a clip where a big fan of the band is being interviewed when she
is surprised by Martha Davis showing up to say hello and members of
the original band give an extended interview about the early glory
days of the band and its great work.
-
Nicholas Sheffo