Under The Covers –
Volume One (Matthew Sweet &
Susanna Hoffs)
(CD)
Sound: B Music:
B+
The one on one duet album has become a lost art. Of course, there have been plenty of duet
albums where one star sings 15 duets, but all with different artists. However, it is a long way from the days of
Marvin Gaye and his various vocal partners, Roberta Flack & Donny Hathaway
or the few other such projects that usually worked. Now, the great singer/songwriter Matthew Sweet pairs up with the
underrated Susanna Hoffs for Under The Covers – Volume One, a new album
of remarkable cover songs as good in tasteful choices as in terrific
performances. The duo have been part of
the Austin Powers in-house band (bet you didn’t realize the film
franchise had one) called Ming Tea, itself a referential in-joke to one of the
many earlier films Mike Myers has pastiched into the framed film series.
The songs here are:
1. I See The Rain (The Marmalade)
2. And Your Bird Can Sing (The Beatles)
3. It's All Over Now, Baby Blue (Bob Dylan)
4. Who Knows Where The Time Goes? (Fairport
Convention)
5. Cinnamon Girl (Neil Young And Crazy Horse)
6. Alone Again Or (Love)
7. Warmth Of The Sun (The Beach Boys)
8. Different Drum (The Stone Poneys, featuring
Linda Ronstadt)
9. The Kids Are Alright (The Who)
10. Sunday Morning (The Velvet Underground)
11. Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere (Neil Young
And Crazy Horse)
12. Care Of Cell #44 (The Zombies)
13. Monday Monday (The Mamas And The Papas)
14. She May Call You Up Tonight (The Left Banke)
15.
Run To Me (The Bee Gees)
Well, no doubt these two love great music and this is
great stuff. That they would dare to
take on some of these classics and do such a good job shows how above and
beyond they are of most of their piers and competitors. In the case of tracks 1 and 14, they are
lesser-known cuts by bands only known for a hit or two. The Marmalade had one hit in 1970 with Reflections
Of My Life, while Walk Away Renee is the big 1966 hit by The Left
Banke, often considered the first Art Rock single a year ahead of The Moody
Blues. The covers here of their other
songs show these bands were not getting the respect they deserve.
The cover of The Beatles, The Beach Boys and Bob Dylan are
also lesser-known songs, but obviously by giant acts. The cover of Cinnamon Girl
is so good, they almost make that song their own. I cannot say that as much about The Kids Are Alright, but Different
Drum is formidable and has some of the spirit of the original. As for Sunday Morning, it is a
bittersweet cover that proves the roots of that classic are inescapable. It makes for one of the most unusual tracks
here because the pop sweetness outlining the bulk talent here mixes oddly with
the lyrics.
Monday Monday
reminds me of Hoffs work with The Bangles, specifically on the underrated Eternal
Flame, where her vocals could go wrong considering the material, except
that she never hits a bad note. Though
she is doing the Mama Cass Elliot/Michele Phillips part, it is as distinctive
as their singing on other John Phillips lead-vocals Mamas & The Papas
tracks. Remember how amazing her voice
is, as when her group The Bangles did great backing vocals on Cyndi Lauper’s
fantastic hit Change Of Heart.
Run To Me is one of the
last songs The Bee Gees cut and had a hit with before they went falsettos crazy
in 1975 and this cover is on par with the original, which says something
considering the empathetic vocals on the original 1972 single. Sadly and ironically, with Maurice Gibb gone
and Robin Gibb not participating on the Barry Gibb/Barbra Streisand reunion
project Guilty Pleasures, this cut works far better than what they cut
for that very disappointing album. That
from a critic who loved Guilty (1980) and is a fan of the better works
of Miss Streisand and The Brother Gibb.
The PCM 16bit/44.1kHz is a very goods recording, clear,
distinctive, layered, rich and sonically superior to most albums we have heard
of late. Cheers to the singers’
producing talents, as well as that of engineer Sweet himself. So strong, it demands an SACD release and if
this is not a ringer for multi-platinum sales and multiple Grammy awards, I
can’t imagine what will come out this year that will be better. Easily, Under The Covers – Volume One
is one of 2006’s best albums.
- Nicholas Sheffo
