Buried
(2010/Lionsgate Blu-ray w/DVD) + Paper
Man (2009/MPI Blu-ray) + Happy Every
Afters (2009/IFC/MPI DVD) + How To
Get Ahead In Advertising (1988/Image DVD) + Love Hurts (2008/E1 DVD) + Jack
Goes Boating (2010/Anchor Bay Blu-ray) + RED (2010/Summit Blu-ray) + The
Virginity Hit (2010/Sony DVD)
Picture:
B & C+/B-/C+/C+/C/C+/B/C- Sound: B
& C+/B-/C+/C+/C+/B-/B/C Extras:
C-/C/C/C/C/C+/B-/D Films: C-/C/C/C/C/B-/C+/D
Comedy is
a type of storytelling that is hard to do and its corollary when it comes to
suspense is the thriller. As the genre
has become battered, inserting more serious angles in the humor has been more
commonplace, but is usually not done well.
We now look at eight different recent releases to make this point
starting with two by Ryan Reynolds, a star on the rise who can do comedy and
drama very well.
The most
serious work here is Rodrigo Cortes’ Buried
(2010), yet another “stuck-in-a” tale, this time with Reynolds as visiting Iraq worker
Paul Conroy, who finds himself waking up in a buried coffin alive and trying to
get out. This had some potential, but
the makers are more interested in sticking it to the audience than actually
writing a script that offers something new or something at all. Reynolds is up to the task, but nothing else
here is and this becomes unintentionally funny, not because of Reynolds, but
because it has an idiot plot. Too bad,
because a good actor is wasted despite a good performance.
The 1080p
2.35 X 1 digital High Definition image is dark most of the time since this
takes place in a coffin, but looks as good as it is going to, while the
anamorphically enhanced DVD also included is much weaker and harder to watch,
especially in comparison. The DTS-HD MA
(Master Audio) 7.1 mix is stretching it when it comes to having a
soundfield. This could have worked
monophonically, but is well recorded, while the Dolby Digital 5.1 on the DVD is
weaker, yet sounds more like the originally intended soundmaster. Extras include Original Theatrical Trailers
and Unearthing Buried: The Making Of
Buried. Nothing like a featurette
using the title of the main feature twice!
Reynolds
fares better as the imaginary superhero Captain Excellent in the
Michele/Kiernan Mulroney comedy Paper
Man (2009) with the underrated Jeff Daniels as a writers-block plagued
novelist whose childhood “friend” shows up when his life is entering a few
crises at once. He becomes interested in
a younger lady (Emma Stone) while his relationship with is wife (Lisa Kudrow,
badly cast doing her same tied TV sitcom shtick) who cannot handle what is
going on.
This also
had more potential, especially with some of the cast, but gets too silly for
its own good and is a genre curio (comedy and superhero) at best, which will
become more so when Reynolds’ turn as Green Lantern arrives. Kieran Culkin also turns up and shows how
likable his whole family is on screen and I kept watching to see it get
better. It did not.
The 1080p
1.85 X 1 digital High Definition image is not great all the time and color can
go from being good to being lame, but it could be worse, yet is not what I
would call Blu-ray demo material. The
DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 5.1 mix (miscredited on the sleeve as mere Dolby
Digital 5.1) is also a little weak in the soundfield department, but this is a
low-budget, dialogue-based affair.
Extras include an Original Theatrical Trailers, Making Of featurette and
interesting Extended & Deleted Scenes that show inexperience may have
partly stopped this from being better.
Stephen
Burke’s Happy Every Afters (2009)
has the likable Sally Hawkins in this Irish romp about two weddings about to
happen at once, but she has some issues and some of the involved have been
mis-married… again? This is a bit
convoluted and despite some energy, never really takes off or adds up. Also, I never really laughed at any of it,
but it is mildly amusing, yet never seems to achieve what it is setting out to
do. Tom Riley also stars.
The 1.78
X 1 anamorphically enhanced image is Video Black-weak and makes darker scenes
especially hard to watch. Color can be
good at times and locations are a plus, but the result is mixed overall, while
the Dolby Digital 5.1 is stretching the dialogue-based sound and this is a low
budget production, so expect only so much here too. Extras include an Original Theatrical Trailer
and Interviews.
Richard
E. Grant is always known for comedy, especially in British films and his
starring role in Bruce Robinson’s How To
Get Ahead In Advertising (1988) is back on DVD yet again after a standard
MGM DVD and even Criterion Collection edition.
Now comes a basic DVD edition from Image Entertainment, but no Blu-ray,
which it oddly has not been issued in yet anywhere we know of. This is the first time we have covered it.
Dennis
Bagley (Grant) is an unhappy ad executive whose work is getting to him despite
his superior skill at his job, but things are too good and he starts to loose
it including a bump developing on his shoulder that seems to be taking on a
life of its own. This is supposed to be
a satire, but like Withnail & I
(the previous actor/director collaboration), it did not work for me despite
their freedom to do what they wanted and I like British humor. Rachel Ward is good as the female lead, but
even she cannot save this quirky film from working.
The 1.78
X 1 anamorphically enhanced image is also Video Black-weak and that can make
darker scenes especially hard to watch, yet there are some good shots, though
this is softer overall than it should be, while the Dolby Digital 5.1 is
stretching the dialogue and joke-based soundtrack originally issued in 35mm
prints as older Dolby A-type analog stereo sound. This is also low budget production, so expect
only so much here too. Extras include an
Original Theatrical Trailer and 18 more for other Handmade Films releases.
Grant
tries to recapture his comedy edge in Barra Grant’s Love Hurts (2008) as his 20-year marriage to Amanda (Carrie Ann
Moss) comes to an end when she leaves him.
A young friend (Johnny Pacar) intends to remake him into a popular
ladies’ man, but he has his own issues to resolve as he realizes how plastic
his life has been. Jenna Elfman, Janeane
Garofalo and Camryn Manheim also star, but the results are as flat as Grant’s
older films, save being less quirky.
The 1.85
X 1 anamorphically enhanced image is the weakest of all eight titles on this
list, with poor color and softness throughout that makes this one hard to
watch. The Dolby Digital 5.1 is not too
bad, but this is also joke and dialogue-based, so the soundfield is limited,
but the sound is better than the image.
Extras include Behind The Scenes footage and Cast/Crew Interviews.
Another
actor who can do comedy and drama very well is Philip Seymour Hoffman, who
decided to direct this adaptation of the stage play Jack Goes Boating (2010) and it is the best work on the list as he
plays the title character, trying to find a good relationship. He starts to look and a couple with their own
problems (Daphne Rubin-Vega and John Ortiz) introduce him to Connie (Amy Ryan)
and things start to happen. It is a
combination of light comedy, character study of the people and of the situation
which works more often than you might think, but the best thing Hoffman has
done in this version is to make it not seem like it is stage bound. Performances are good all around and I would
like to see him direct again.
The 1080p
1.85 X 1 digital High Definition image is shot in HD digital video and shows it
with some softness throughout that undermines the viewing at times, but there
are good shots as well and this is nicely directed. The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 mix fares a bit better
by being warm and well-recorded, but (here we go again) this is a low-budget,
dialogue-based mix, so don’t expect a strong soundfield. Extras include Deleted Scenes and two
featurettes: Jack’s New York and From The Stage To The Big Screen.
Based on
a DC Comic, Robert Schwentke’s RED
(2010) is a rare DC project outside of Warner Bros., made by Summit and stars
Bruce Willis as a retired CIA agent about to have his peace interrupted by a
kidnapping… his! He escapes to
investigate and as he unravels what is going on, decides to get his old
espionage gang together. They are all
marked by the title (Retired, Extremely Dangerous) and he is also involved with
a younger woman (Mary-Louise Parker) and wants to get to know her better as he
gets involved in a complicated conflict.
The big
problem is that this is too self-amused for far too long before it really
starts to get moving, but half-way through, it starts to work when the rest of
the main cast (Morgan Freeman, John Malkovich, Helen Mirren) slowly turn
up. It is too late to save this romp,
but it has some good moments and if it had had its act together earlier, could
have been great. Richard Dreyfus and
Brian Cox also show up in key roles, as well as Karl Urban (who is getting
better as an actor) as the younger CIA agent out to get Willis. Seeing what I see, Summit has already greenlit a sequel. Let’s see what they’ll do with that one.
The 1080p
2.35 X 1 digital High Definition image was shot with a RED One HD camera and
this results in sometimes odd color and moments that range from decent to
phony, not even counting the digital visual effects. The DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 5.1 mix is rich
and warm, if not offering the best soundfield possible, but it is the
best-sounding of the titles covered here and has some good sonic moments. Extras include Access Red interactive
features with Cast/Crew Interviews et al, amusing Extended & Deleted Scenes
and feature length audio commentary by former CIA operative and Field Officer Robert
Baer that is even more interesting than the main feature. Watch RED
before listening to him, though.
Finally
we have a disaster called The Virginity
Hit (2010), directed (if you can call it that) by Andrew Gurland and Huck
Botko (it took two people to make this mess?!?!?) about some idiotic teens who
have decided to loose their virginity on line and make it an event. Then a porn star shows up and wow, who
thought any of this was funny? The idea
is to have this become a cult item for a younger audience, but it is so smug,
condescending and cynical that what’s the use?
That this was in a movie theater is stunning, but it reminds us of how Blair Witch permanently damaged
cinematic integrity for a younger audience and the industry. This from those who gave us the unfunny Step Brothers, but this is worse! Wow, is this bad.
The 1.85
X 1 anamorphically enhanced image is the weakest of all eight titles and just
about anything I have seen form a major studio on DVD lately, with awful
low-def digital video all over the place, awful color, bad editing, softness and
other endless visual flaws that make an 8-bit Atari 2600 image seem advanced. The Dolby Digital 2.0 sound is barely stereo
and has plenty of volume drops, so this is also very sloppy. Extras include a featurette calling itself “Jersey Girl” (these guys love to tempt
fate apparently), a Line-O-Rama section, Zack’s
Funny Or Die Audition, Screen Tests and Cast/Crew feature length audio
commentary track.
Not too
many laughs here, so choose wisely or not at all.
- Nicholas Sheffo