Citizen
Koch (2013/MPI
DVD)/Fracknation
(2012/Magnolia/MagNet Blu-ray)/Fuhrer
Cult & Megalomania
(2011) + Siege Of
Leningrad (2013/First Run
DVDs)
Picture:
C+/B-/C+/C+ Sound: C+/B-/C+/C+ Extras: B-/C-/D/D
Documentaries: B+/C-/B-/B-
Here's
some new documentary releases for you to know about, including one
that was censored.
That
film would be Carl Dean & Tia Lessin's Citizen
Koch
(2013) which was originally intended as a PBS event film, but was
censored since PBS now only gets 15% of its funding from the
government via taxpayers and the Koch (pronounced Coke) Brothers have
made millions of dollars in contributions to PBS of late. They got
the film killed in a sad day for public television and journalism.
So what were they so afraid of?
The
action takes place in Wisconsin where Scott Walker campaigned as a
moderate conservative and turned out to be a union busting extremist
who suckered enough Reagan-type Democrats and Independents to vote
him in. The resulting disaster was the immediate targeting of unions
and their political funding and activities in one of the most
anti-democratic, anti-American events in recent U.S. politics. This
made the people in the state angry enough to get a recall vote going
to get rid of Walker, but suddenly legal anonymous money flowed into
the state favoring walker and as a test run of how to ruin voting
nationwide, many ultra-Right wing entities (led expllicity by the
Koch Brothers) outspent democrats and grass roots people 8-to-1,
resulting in Walker staying.
Very
ugly. The film starts with a film that never got released: Hillary
The Movie,
the poison pill propaganda film that led to the Supreme Court saying
corporations somehow had freedom of speech and could spend as many
billions (with a B) of dollars ads they wanted on candidates and do
it secretly through Super PAC organizations. We will not even go
into the issues with that, though it does allow foreign money to come
in, which itself is a big problem. Fortunately, more and more people
have caught onto what is going on here like in the madness of
fracking across the country, no matter the environmental
consequences.
Nice
touch to start it like Welles' Citizen
Kane
(1941), but we do not get a work about Hillary, but about how the
rich have not only failed democracy and the true promise of America
as Welles' classic did, but how we now have explicitly, vicious rich
people who are on a tear that most people would never approve of. A
remarkable film in itself, the truth hurts and that is why the film
had to be stopped, at least temporarily. Nice to see it hitting DVD
in time for the 2014 midterm elections and beyond. No matter who you
are or what your political leanings are, this is a must-see
documentary.
Extras
include Deleted & Extended Scenes, the Original Theatrical
Trailer, Sundance
Film Fest: Meet The Artists
for this film and Big
Brother On Film
with a screening hosted by Michael Moore.
The
premise of Fracknation
(2012), which somehow took three directors to make despite being only
77 minutes (!!!) is that the Award-Winning Gasland
documentary about the dangers of fracking (breaking underground earth
crust to free it of natural gas) is flawed and some how dishonest.
The team (led by narrator/co-director Phelim McAleer) raised their
money to make this release via a web fundraising site, so in advance,
we are told this is totally independent and the makers represent
total truth and honesty. However, what could have been an honest
documentary saying fracking has its advantages or might not be as bad
as others are saying turns out to be a propaganda flick with master
manipulation only matched by its condescending attitude.
No
points are ever totally argued well, finding possible flaws in
someone else's work does not invalidate their entire work and then in
the topper, pleasant animation reminiscent of those drug ads where
they tell you everything is great while warning you of a laundry list
of deadly side effects under their breath (we get no such whispering
here) talks of fracking as if it were as natural, easy and harmless
as ordering a pizza. The best part is when they talk of some
chemicals
being put into the ground without naming them or their deadly
side-effects, but that is how juvenile this one gets. This is just a
Right-wing work not so cleverly disguised as indie journalism and I
was not fooled. You should not be either.
Trailers
are the only extras, which is no surprise in this case, but BD Live
functions are sadly included as well
Adding
to their stable of great releases on WWII, the Nazis and The
Holocaust, First Run has issued to more recent programs worth your
time running just under an hour and made by Michael Kloft. Fuhrer
Cult & Megalomania
(2011) examines how Hitler was building a massive shine to himself
and the assumed success of the Nazis winning WWII that would have
been finished by the mid-1950s. It is a remarkable new look behind
the scenes at just how pompous they were equaling their
murderousness. Then we have Siege
Of Leningrad
(2013) which gets to the ugly side of how an unprepared Stalin threw
his people under the truck (and tanks, et al) when the Nazis invaded
Leningrad breaking the so-called non-aggression pact and trying to
take over the Soviet Union.
Instead,
many Nazis died, but so did Soviets and most who resisted had zero
weapons, uniforms or the means to defend themselves, so they
literally were killed on sight. The scorched earth policy trapped
many a Nazi and many were captured and/or killed, but those in the
city had so little food that they even resorted to cannibalism! This
was a mostly untold story until the USSR collapsed by 1990. Ugly but
true, Kloft handles the subject matter extremely well, but know that
both programs have their darkness and some viewers may find some of
the content disturbing.
There
are no extras on either release, unfortunately.
The
1080p 1.78 X 1 digital High Definition image on Fracknation
is not a great presentation with its mix of video footage, but it is
sadly the best presentation on the list, which says something about
the choppy nature of documentary and propaganda films. As compared
to the other, better works, its relative cleanness is actually
suspect in addition to its content. The
anamorphically enhanced 1.78 X 1 image on the 3 DVDs here come in a
close second to the presentation just the same with the film footage
of the Nazi programs in sometimes impressively good shape (outside of
the black & white Triumph
Of The Will
clips, we get real full color footage (early color Agfa film) that
can be chilling) and play just fine for their formats.
As
for sound, Fracknation
offers a DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 2.0 Stereo lossless mix on that is
again only marginally better than the lossy Dolby Digital 5.1 on Koch
and lossy Dolby Digital 2.0 Stereo on all the DVDs, but again not by
much. All have more than passable sound.
-
Nicholas Sheffo