Anna
Christie (1930*)/Cabin In The Sky (1943*)/A Day At The
Races (1937*)/Faithless (1932/*all MGM/Warner Archive
Blu-rays)/That Uncertain Feeling (1941/MVD/VCI Blu-ray)
Picture:
B-/B/B/B/C+ Sound: C+/B-/B-/B-/C+ Extras: C+/B-/B/C/C-
Films: C+/C+/B/B-/B-
PLEASE
NOTE:
The Anna
Christie,
Cabin
In The Sky,
A Day
At The Races
and Faithless
Blu-rays
are now only available from Warner Bros. through their Warner Archive
series and all can be ordered from the link below.
Now
for some classic comedy, including by some of the best journeyman
filmmakers, artists, and auteurs ever and the great on camera talent
ever seen...
Clarence
Brown's Anna Christie
(1930) was a breakthrough film for Greta Garbo, the big screen silent
beauty slowly making her transition to sound (this was her first
sound film) and film more than just surviving it, but thriving.
However, because of her star status, many wondered if she could play
a serious role and as a prostitute with personal issues, but she
pulled it off and the result was another early sound hit. The film
takes a little longer than you might expect today to really start,
but it starts working well enough once she arrives.
Based
on a Eugene O'Neill Pulitzer Prize-winning play, she is good in it
and supporting turns by Charles Bickford as her new love interest who
does not know about her past, Marie Dressler and George F. Marion are
fine and well cast for the limited cast we get. But it is Garbo who
ultimately delivers and though the film has a few off moments, worth
a good look and it is a pre-Hollywood Code film, so it has some
then-racy items too.
Jacques
Feyder directed the German-language version also included here and it
is not bad and similar enough to be as watchable and at least as
interesting, with a totally different cast (save Garbo) and is only 4
minutes shorter.
Extras
include the already noted German version of the film, a Garbo career
retrospective on the TV series MGM Parade, 2/7/1938 radio
drama episode version of the film on The Lux Radio Theater
with Joan Crawford in Garbo's lead role and the classic 1930 Looney
Tunes animated cartoon The Booze Hangs High.
Vincente
Minnelli's Cabin In The Sky
(1943) is the first of two films we have here that have some great
music and great African American performers, but they get the top MGM
studio treatment at the horrific price of being stuck in racial
stereotype and other racist tropes. The studio gives them one of
their best directors, plus some work by also-legendary Busby
Berkeley, the legendary Arthur Freed musical production unit and paid
for one of the best casts you could have for a musical at any time.
Ethel Waters, Lena Horne, Louis Armstrong, Duke Ellington & His
Orchestra, Jack Benny comedy veteran Eddie 'Rochester' Anderson, Rex
Ingram, Butterfly McQueen, Bill Bailey and a fired-up cast often save
this film from itself with some priceless moments when it takes a
break from its rather bizarre narrative.
It
can be very hard to watch and especially by today's standards, almost
schizophrenic. Anderson's Little Joe is a gambler who gets shot and
killed, but gets a second chance to come back to the world of the
living and correct things. Then we get religious references,
conjurings of The Devil himself and this sad idea that the characters
have to alternatives to a better life; one with economic
opportunities, dignity, the promise of a better tomorrow and much,
much more. Still, that the most powerful movie studio of the time
felt it was worth the economic risk of making even this film speaks
to the undeniable talent on the screen and reminds us of the
priceless contributions of African Americans to all of music in the
United States. Worth a look if you can get past its permanent
issues.
Extras
include, a feature length audio commentary track by Eddie 'Rochester'
Anderson's wife Evangela and daughter Eva, African American Culture
Scholar Todd Boyd and an except of an interview with Lena Horne by
film scholar Drew Casper, audio outtake of Louis Armstrong singing
Ain't It The Truth, vintage live action Pete Smith short
Studio Visit and an Original Theatrical Trailer.
Sam
Wood's A Day At The Races
(1937) remains one of the best films with The Marx Brothers, and
though it has some issues here and there, it has some of the funniest
and most brilliant comedy in cinema history with Groucho, Chico and
Harpo recreate the energy, charm and brilliance of
A Night At The Opera.
Even when this film has minor issues, they are so incredible and
unforgettable together and funny beyond belief, that any such moments
are left in the dust.
Chico
works as a driver for a local sanitarium that is in trouble, with its
current owner (Maureen O'Sullivan from the Tarzan
films, et al) is being bullied into selling it and allowing its needy
residents to be pushed out, things take and unexpected twist when a
rich visitor (Margaret Dumont, always underrated and brilliant) hears
that her favorite doctor might be coming to run the place. This is a
lie Chico has made up because he merely heard her talk highly of the
man, so he sends out a request and Dr. Hackensack (Groucho!) arrives
as all madness breaks loose!
In
addition to this, Harpo is a horse jockey at a gambling race track
that Chico also goes to, but he loves gambling, which is not easy
since his funds are limited. With the institution in jeopardy, can
they pick a winning horse that will save them all? All these decades
later, it is a comedy classic for a reason.
However,
there is one sequence in the middle and that is one where Harpo finds
a group of young black children at the institution and starts playing
the flute as they sing about Gabriel's horn and it becomes the film's
second biggest musical sequence in what is not necessarily a musical.
An adult African American
jazz group then also happens to show up and join in and the point is
supposed to be unity, but it gets lopsided by racism and a highly
unfortunate end to the sequence that kills most of the good will.
Too bad.
Allan
Jones becomes the owner's love interest and we get more great
supporting work by Sig Ruman, Douglass Dumbrille, Leonard Ceeley,
Robert Middlemass, plus Richard Farnsworth, Kenny Baker, Hopper
Atchley, W.C. Fields and Dorothy Dandridge are also apparently in the
film somewhere. The casting is as key, with the chemistry of all
involved still remarkable to this day and Irving Thalberg was one of
the reasons, though the brothers were in prime form by this time,
Thalberg's passing hurt this film and the trio would never hit
cinematic heights his high again, most unfortunately.
Cuts
did not help this film, including two musical numbers and some other
items that could have stayed, yet this is still their longest film
and you can see why people still talk about it, why it is still
celebrated and remains a legendary comedy. Of course, the great Rock
band Queen named two of their most important albums after this film
and A Night At The Opera,
a decision that seems more and more brilliant as each year passes by.
But the bottom line is, this film is one of the great comedies that
has been rarely matched or surpassed, and this beautiful restorations
one of the best we've seen in a while, which says something.
Warner
Archive has the rights to their last four MGM films and their lone
RKO film, so I hope they are up next for the same treatment, even if
they are not always as highly regarded. Remaining one of the
greatest comedy teams of all time, they deserve the top rate
treatment and so do we!
Extras
includes a solid feature length audio commentary track by Marx
Brothers Encyclopedia author Glenn Mitchell that is definitely worth
listening to after watching the film, though he does not talk all the
way through, is a great early track, plus we get the featurette On
Your Marx, Get Set, Go!, an Original Theatrical Trailer, a
live action MGM Robert Benchley short A Night At The Movies,
unused audio-only section by Groucho of his Dr. Hackenbush character
in the film, outtake of the cut song A Message From The Man On The
Moon, Leo Is On The Air radio promo for the film and the
classic MGM animated cartoons: Gallopin'
Gals, Mama's
New Hat and Old
Smokey. That makes this
a must-see, must-buy disc!
For
more restored Marx Bros., try our coverage of the previous hit film,
A Night At The Opera
on Blu-ray at this link:
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/15989/Free+Guy+4K+(2021/20th+Century/Disney+4K+Ul
Harry
Beaumont's Faithless
(1932) is an early Tallulah Bankhead film where she is the daughter
of a very rich father, but it is the late 1920s, which means the big
stock market crash is on the way and The Great Depression immediately
follows. She turns down a young man named Bill (Robert Montgomery)
who only makes a mere $20,000 dollars a year (even adjusted over nine
decades later, she and her family are far wealthier) for marriage,
then the bottom falls out.
Instead
of changing her mind, she lands up with a rich and abusive goof, then
things get even worse, though Bill is still interested. I won't give
much more away, but the film is a comedy, but has a darker side
because it has to. The enduring journeyman director Beaumont is more
than able to handle it all and Bankhead is incredible in her early
prime here. I really liked this and it is definitely worth going out
of your way for. Hugh Herbert, Maurice Murphy, Louise Closser Hale,
Henry Kolker, Lawrence Grant and another great, though uncredited,
turn by the great Sterling Holloway make for a solid supporting cast.
Definitely recommended.
Extras
include three live action short subjects: Rambling Around Radio
Row #18, The Trans-Atlantic Mystery and The
Symphonic Murder Mystery, with director W.S. Van Dyke (The
Thin Man, Tarzan The Ape Man, Manhattan Melodrama)
involved as a real plus for these underrated gems.
That
leaves us with Ernst Lubitsch's That
Uncertain Feeling
(1941) has Merle Oberon and Melvyn Douglas happily married, but one
day, she meets a pianist played by Burgess Meredith and starts to
doubt her marriage when she has a case of the hiccups so severe, she
sees a medical doctor. This is the kind of film the great director
could pull off in ways almost no one else could and was on a roll
with hit classics like The
Merry Widow,
Angel,
Bluebeard's
Eighth Wife,
Ninotchka,
The
Shop Around The Corner
and after this film, To
Be Or Not To Be.
He
was already a well known, successful director in the silent era when
he moved to Hollywood, sound arrived and the top studios in town
brought him in. I think it is a very good film, but one of our
fellow writers really loves it and you can read more as we previously
reviewed this gem via the old Roan Group DVD edition
at this link:
http://www.fulvuedrive-in.com/review/3241/That+Uncertain+Feeling+(Roan+Group
We
also get extras this time, with a so-so condition copy of the Daffy
Duck cartoon short Henpecked
Duck from the same year
as the film and Castle
Films News Parade of 1941.
Now
for playback performance. The 1080p 1.33 X 1 black & white
digital High Definition image transfers on all four Warner Archive
releases can show the age of the materials used, but the results are
far superior to all previous releases of the film on home video and
some of the shots on some of them are stunning. Anna
Christie suffers from its
age, but they gave repaired and cleaned things as much as possible.
There are some great shots of Garbo too. Cabin
and Faithless
will surprise viewers, but for whatever reason including the money
that was put into the film A
Day At The Races has more
than a few demo shots ands the MGM monochromatic gloss kicks in
during a few scenes that are demo-worthy for any system. In all
cases, it makes the comedy work better too.
The
DTS-HD MA (Master Audio) 2.0 Mono lossless mixes on the four Warner
Archive releases are restored from their original theatrical mono
releases and sound as good as they likely ever will. Anna
Christie
is the oldest film here and even the most powerful studio in
Hollywood could only deliver sound so good the first few years of
sound on film, so notice how many scenes are talking characters
staying in one place because the microphones were only so good. The
results can be a little rough or limited, but they were a revelation
at the time.
Finally,
the 1080p 1.33 X 1 black & white digital High Definition image on
Feeling is a recycle of the older Roan Group DVD, but looks a
little better with the Video Black a little stronger, though the film
still needs some work. The PCM 2.0 Mono is also a slight improvement
over the old, lossy, weak Dolby Digital from that old DVD, yet could
also use some work. This is the best this will play until a full new
4K restoration can be done.
To
order any or all four of the Warner Archive Blu-ray releases covered
here, go to this link for them and many more great web-exclusive
releases at:
https://www.amazon.com/stores/page/ED270804-095F-449B-9B69-6CEE46A0B2BF?ingress=0&visitId=6171710b-08c8-4829-803d-d8b922581c55&tag=blurayforum-20
-
Nicholas Sheffo